Showing posts with label Bizarre. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Bizarre. Show all posts

Saturday, October 20, 2012

Out of Place Artefacts: Eyebrow-Raisers and Eye-Poppers - Bizarre History Blog

Posted by Beachcombing in : Ancient, Medieval , trackback

***Dedicated to Amanda and BFM***

Bad Archaeology, a necessarily quarrelsome but very worthwhile corner of the internet, is presently hosting an article on Out of Place Artefacts: objects that have turned up in places or in times where they would not be expected. As readers of Strange History will know the present author has frequently dealt with such things under the wrong place, wrong time tags and so he ran to this post with much interest. Yet he came away, given the very high standards associated with the writer in question, Brian Fitzpatrick-Matthews, a little disappointed. Why? Well, BFM has dedicated much of his life to fighting the Von Danikenites, the Ultra Diffusionists and the Pre-Columbian Exchange Exchangers: and good for him. But here Brian is so dedicated to the destruction of archaeological heresy that he spends his time shooting at those who are never going to drop dead – he’d need silver bullets for that – instead of enjoying  some of archaeology’s most curious discoveries. Brian’s post did though stimulate some crude thoughts that are offered up here to be mocked or expanded as readers wish: drbeachcombing AT yahoo DOT com

Any object dug out of the ground can be put into one of four categories. We have:

(i) the nod category: Etruscan pottery in antique central Italy – nothing happening, move on.

(ii) the shrug category: African red slip ware in an early medieval Irish harbour – exotic but not worth contacting the media over.

(iii) the raised eye-brow category: Roman beads in Japan – write a press release and expect tenure!

(iv) the eye-popping category: a Babylonian cuneiform in Montana – where to even begin…

The real points of interest here are (iii) and (iv) and the difficult boundary between them. (iii) involves discoveries that should excite us but that do not require us to rewrite our text books. For example, those Roman glass beads in Japan point to lines of communication between Europe and Asia in Antiquity and the early Middle Ages. It will, of course, take our breath away to see an object created in Roman Italy in a medieval ‘shogun’’s tomb. But remember we can establish that those lines of communication existed without recourse to archaeology. These finds provide anecdotes for the lecture hall and colourful footnotes: they are not though game changers.

Think now, instead, of (iv), and the Babylonian cuneiform that turned up in the bag of a nineteenth-century American Indian, a find that has been used to suggest pre Columbian contacts between the ancient Near East and North America. Were that find to be accepted by the archaeological community then it would change everything. The text books would not just have to be rewritten: they would have to be SHREDDED.

How do archaeologists react to category (iii) and (iv)? In Beach’s experience archaeologists attitudes towards raised-eye-brow artefacts (iii) depend, reasonably enough, on the conditions under which the objects were found. If an object is discovered in an official archaeological dig then archaeologists get excited: for example, see the comments over the seventh-century Asian buckle (made of iron) that turned up in a dig at Cape Espenberg (Alaska).

When, however, an eyebrow-raising object is found by a metal detector or by an amateur then archaeologists will be sceptical or downright offensive: like most professional groups, archaeologists hate to feel that their legs are being pulled. Beach’s favourite example of this is the Viking Maine Penny dug up by a Sunday archaeologist in 1956. There is nothing really game changing about the Maine Penny. It suggests a slightly larger window, chronologically speaking, for Viking activity in North America, but nothing qualitatively new. It certainly need not suggest Greenland visits to New England. After all, Indian trade networks could easily have carried the coin from Labrador, say, to Maine.  Yet archaeologists (and historians) smell rotten fish here and most are reluctant to accept the Maine penny into the corpus. The result of excessive paranoia?

How do archaeologists react to eye-popping finds (iv)? Well, first of all, and this is crucial, eye-popping finds rarely turn up in professional digs. In fact, works like Forbidden Archaeology rely overwhelmingly on pre-professional era digs for their evidence. There are two possible explanations for this. First, most eye-popping finds depend on fakery or grotesque misunderstandings. Or, second, archaeologists systematically cover up their eye-popping finds and are all part of David Icke’s lizard tribe dedicated to keeping humanity in the outer darkness.

The present author has problems with archaeologists generally: he lived for too many years under their tyranny as a historian for a period for which few texts survive. But he does not think archaeologists have it in them to systematically hide the truth (which is ‘out there’) from us mere mortals in such a dastardly fashion. Nor does he take the Fortean argument about ‘damned’ data very seriously. Yes, modern archaeologists might draw some excavated battlements wrong to suit tastes. But they would find it more difficult to deny that they had found a Portuguese canon ball in, say, a village from sixteenth-century Australia were that canon ball to actually turn up. There is though demonstrably, among some parts of the general public, a desire to create fake archaeological finds, a desire that could explain, for example, all or the vast majority of ‘pre-Columbian’ artefacts from North America. Another explanation might be earlier planters…

Examples where eye-popping finds have been made in carefully run archaeologically digs are few and far between. A famous instance is the aluminum belt in third-century China: in this post we have concentrated on geographical rather than time anomalies, so it is nice to offer up one instance of an impossibly (?) early technology. The attitude of western archaeologists towards this find has generally been respectful, because the find took place in another archaeological tradition. But the most recent study from the west suggests that this was a fake worked on professionals (or by professionals?). The explanation lacks proof and is border-line libelous, but it may be our best way out, at least until someone comes along and explains how these belts bits could have been created in ancient China.

Another example of eye-popping finds depends on bodies rather than archaeological artefacts, namely, the discovery of nicotine and cocaine in Egyptian mummies: something that was taken by some to demonstrate Barry-Fell-like contact with the New World. Here we had laboratory data from a very reliable source (Svetlana Balabanova) which practically sucked eye-balls out of the head: and yet there it was, New World substances in the Old World three thousand years before Columbus!

What did archaeologists and Egyptologists do when confronted with this data? In most cases, and this shows the less heroic sides of these disciplines, they ran for cover as quickly as their legs would carry them: some making unpleasant insinuations about the professional qualifications of the relevant lab workers. In fact, at least part of the answer was that nicotine came from locally occurring plants. The cocaine was never explained but may have come from false readings the result of previous tests in the original lab. This, it has to be said, seems unlikely, but it is so much more likely than a cocaine trade with ancient Mexico that left no other significant traces…

In the end the quality of archaeology (or any discipline) will depend on its ability to receive occasional eye-popping finds. After all, sometimes text books need to be torn up, and certainly our twenty-first century text books are different, in fundamentals, from those of the late nineteenth century. Take, an example, from this author’s fevered imagination. Let us ‘pretend’ that some Meso-American finds appeared in digs in the wreck of a tenth-century Japanese village: something which is unlikely, but not beyond the realms of all possibility. Archaeologists establish that Shinichi Fujimura has had nothing to do with the dig and then settle down and absorb the fact that the ‘impossible’ has come out of the ground on a shovel. The final test of any intellectual tradition will be whether that tradition can bend and twist with new evidence, or whether it will just snap like a dry reed. An example that shows archaeologists bending is Monte Verde for pre-Clovis settlement in the Americas: debate was  sometimes acrimonious (to say the least), but the archaeologists who came out the other side were still scientists.

This is where Beachcombing has problems with Brian’s arguments in the post advertised above. In a climactic part of that post Brian writes:

the [internet] sites that present information to counter the claims of Bad Archaeologists tend to do it piecemeal, answering specific bits of data, such as individual out-of-place artefacts. There is little by way of large-scale, overarching argumentation.

Make no mistake, large-scale argumentation is the last thing that archaeology or Joe Bloggs need: apart perhaps from the fundamental point that eye-popping finds rarely appear in scientifically-organised digs. ‘Large-scale argumentation’ leads to empirical facts being sacrificed to theory and means that when/if that pre-Columbian find in a tenth-century Japanese village is made archaeology will be less likely to register said find for what it is. Instead, what is needed are small, careful studies online of each and every anomalous find, particularly the eye-popping ones. The present author will give an example that made a great impression on him. When he wrote about cocaine and nicotine in Egyptian mummies, one of the mega factoids of the internet age, he was unable to find any, let us call them, ‘establishment’ arguments. It was only when Egyptologist David Counsell very kindly wrote in with an explanation (at least for the nicotine) that the problem began to straighten itself out. Forget overarching theories. If a general reader types in ‘mummies’ ‘cocaine’ and ‘nicotine’ on google.com and if that reader doesn’t get a good non pre-Columbian explanation on the first page of his or her search then we have all failed.

***

16 Oct 2012: Villy B has sent this comment in: I enjoy learning more about ancient out-of-place artifacts. I think this stems from reading too much sci-fi as a child. I find few to be credible, though they can be entertaining. Some of the most interesting, if least believable, are those that require alien or pre-human/very early human sources. As one example there have been gold chains (and other objects) reported from Illinois coals (about 300 million years in age). Such finds (if true) have interesting implications, but you have to wonder why anyone (or anything?), in any time period, would be wandering around in vast swamps losing gold chains. More likely we would be finding in a swamp the equivalents of modern garbage-bottles and cans and the like. Closer to our own times is the finding of Roman empire age coins in the eastern USA, a few from the area where I live.  I can believe it remotely possible that a Roman ship or two (or other pre-Columbian visitors including Prince Madoc, a local favorite here in the Ohio River valley) could have been very lost or perhaps drifted to North America’s east coast via Atlantic currents. To then trek hundreds of miles inland to drop a few coins or carve a few ambiguous faces or letters in stone (as the Brandenburg Stone and others, Madoc again here in part)seems unlikely in the extreme. A better explanation for at least some of these coins is a forgotten colonial tradition of gifting coins at weddings (as a symbol of prosperity and the “something old” of the rhyme).Coins from the “time of  Jesus”, or close to it, being considered auspicious. Coins later be lost and refound. Among the strangest of modern claims for out-of-place artifacts that I know of has to be those from “Burrows Cave” (lots online for this one,very entertaining story). These artifacts, if real, would indicate centuries of pre-Columbian travel to interior North America. The claim is also made that Alexander the Great is buried in the cave! Hard to believe under any circumstances, harder still to believe when all the artifacts are so crude and artistically similar, though from different traditions. Even harder to believe authenticity when the “gold” artifacts are (from the pictures online anyway) obviously “gold” painted complete with brush marks (should of used spray paint guys)! I could talk about many more, but I hope these give my general take on the matter. Real OOPA are out there I think, but they have to be proven to be believed. Proof often seems less important than agendas in many of these cases. Where Bad Archeology says “The sites that present information to counter the claims of Bad Archaeologists tend to do it piecemeal, answering specific bits of data, such as individual out-of-place artifacts. There is little by way of large-scale, overarching argumentation.”, I have to ask where is your “overarching argumentation” when you give us supposed artifacts in a piecemeal fashion? If we can’t look at each artifact (or “specific bits of data” as he says) on its’ own merits and provenance, what answer(s) are they really looking for?  He also states “Archaeology needs better advocates than vapid television “personalities””-most of the vapid television “personalities” I’ve seen are the “bad archeologists” (most recently on the Ancient Aliens programs).’ Thanks VB

Wednesday, October 3, 2012

Varla Ventura On Real Life Horrors And The Totally Bizarre (Video) - Examiner

Real life horrors and the totally bizarre just in time for Halloween with author Varla Ventura. Known for her books on bizarre real life stories and several collections at Weiser books on the paranormal. We will discuss this and more in this journey through the underworld in our interview. It is interviews like this that make me darkly glad about what I do. Puts a new dark flare into my body and warped soul. Just in time for our jovial time of doom and glee, as we approach the almighty All Hallow's Eve. I hope you will enjoy this thrilling dash of blood and gore as much as I have. Also if you have any paranormal tales or tales of horror you'd like to share to be featured in future articles you can email them to mabusincarnate@gmail.com

1. Could you tell us what your prime motivation was in creating your two books Book of the Bizarre: Freaky Facts and Strange Stories and Beyond Bizarre: Frightening Facts and Blood-Curdling True Tales?

VV: I’ve always been a fan Ripley’s Believe it or Not and strange science and trivia, and I tended to retain these odd stories for years and years. I’d pull them out at a cocktail party—did you know that duck dander was once believed to be hallucinogenic?—and at one party my friend Pirate Chris asked me if I’d ever thought about writing a book of these odd facts. A light bulb lit up over my head! So my prime motivation was selfish: I just wanted a place to collect all the odd stories and trivia I’d gathered over the years. Scaring people, entertaining them, and grossing them out is just a little bonus!

2. Would you tell us about the series of books Weiser Books: Magical Creatures and Paranormal Parlor and what themes they exactly touch on?

VV: Both of these collections are resurrections of volumes of forgotten lore. The Magical Creatures collection focuses on supernatural creatures—including changelings, pookas, vampires, banshees, werewolves, mermaids—their habits and habitats, classical myths, and in the case of something like a vampire or werewolf even some old fiction stories. The Paranormal Parlor series is a collection of true tales of haunting, sĂ©ances, psychic phenomena, as well as ghost stories, particularly of the Victorian drawing-room era.

3. In your Book of the Bizarre you mention the Transylvanian Tablets and since I have a Dracula aka Vlad the Impaler fetish would you tell us the tale?

VV: Yes! That is such a cool story. In 1961 archaeologists digging into a prehistoric mound in the Transylvanian village of Tartaria discovered several small clay tablets with bizarre inscriptions on them. Some believed the inscriptions to be sigils or magical signs, and others believed that they were important documents left behind for the singular purpose of being found—time capsules, perhaps. Using the modern method of carbon dating, the objects’ origin was placed at around 4000 B.C. The writing was believed to be of Mesopotamian origin, specifically Sumerian, the first written language. This suggests that the first evidence of writing could have begun in the backwoods of Transylvania!

The tablets were found in the lowest layer of the dig, in a sacrificial pit within a burial mound, and the pit also contained some scattered human bones. The bones bore symbols quite similar to the inscriptions on the tablets; the symbols were both from Sumer and from the highly advanced Minoan civilizations of Crete. But if the carbon dating is accurate, the tablets were made by a primitive Stone Age agricultural tribe known as the Vinca. The Vinca predated Sumerian writing by one millennium and the Minoan writing by two thousand years. Most scholars believe that the inscriptions were magical ciphers—spells and secret codes of this ancient farming tribe.

As an aside, if you are a Bram Stoker fan, in the Magical Creatures series I have several things of interest. One, The Vampyre, is the first vampire story published in English, predating Dracula by 70 years. It was written by John William Polidori who was, among many things, Lord Byron’s personal physician. Also, Stoker’s widow released a collection of short stories just after his death, and I’ve included two of them in my collection. The Burial of Rats and Dracula’s Guest. They are both amazing!

4. With Halloween vastly approaching out of all of your books what story would you like to share to get us in the mood of ghosts and ghouls?

VV: How about a story of real life horror?

Dr. Joseph McDowell was a prominent Missouri doctor widely considered to be a brilliant surgeon in 1840s St. Louis. Having taken up residence in Hannibal, Missouri, the doctor also gained a reputation for being eccentric. When his own daughter died as a young girl, he preserved her in a cask and hid the cask in a cave. He was also a reputed bodysnatcher, who would remove bodies from cemeteries for the purpose of teaching his students medical science—a practice not unusual for doctors of the time. But when the body of a young girl went missing, the townspeople demanded that he return it. McDowell, forewarned by the ghost of his own mother, hid the body before anyone could find it. In addition to his gruesome practices, McDowell was also reputed to keep a pet bear.

5. What exactly is the Magickal Skull of Doom and how did you come about the story?

VV: Ah, the skull of doom! The story goes that in 1920s this crystal skull turned up under an altar in an archeological excavation in the great Mayan city ruins of Lubaantun, what is now known as Belize. While other crystal skulls have been discovered in Central American ruins, none can match the Skull of Doom for its perfection of craftsmanship and likeness to a real skull. It actually is made refract light in such a way that the eye sockets glow!

Mystery surrounds the skull. It is debated if it is actually pre-Columbian. It is said it is made of crystal that appears to be from what we now call California, not in the Mayan territory, lending to the theory that it is not actually a remnant from Lubaantun and was “placed” there by its “discoverer.” Who knows, for certain? Certainly the archeological practices of the 1920s had very different standards than archeology of today.

But the best part of the story is the doom part, of course. Frederick Mitchell Hedges, one of the archaeologists present at the discovery, is the one rumored to have planted it. He proclaimed that the skull was “used by the high priest of the Maya to concentrate on and will death,” that it was “the embodiment of all evil.” He also said anyone who scoffed at the skull’s powers have died or “have been stricken and become seriously ill.” He is the one who declared it the Skull of Doom.
One of the later owners of the skull, Frank Dortland, swore it gave off an eerie perfume and emanated a sound similar to chiming bells! He also said it could change color at will and that it it sometimes was filled with ever-changing, cloudy images and at other times it contained crystal-clear images of temples, mountains, and myriad other striking scenes. Other folks who observed the skull when it was under Dortland’s watch said a hazy aura would occasionally enshroud it. Still stranger are the reports of physiological phenomena, such as a quickening of the pulse, muscle spasms in the legs and arms, and even eye twitching, affecting people who were near the skull.

Don’t you just want one all your own?

6. In your second book Beyond Bizarre you have a chapter called Gross Anatomy: Hospital Horrors. What does it embody exactly horror wise?

VV: That chapter is all about medical maladies and other medicine-related atrocities as well as a few haunted hospitals and asylums. There are details of a woman with a worm in her brain, a baby born with part of a foot in its brain, the use of maggots as medical devices (you can even get a prescription!), horrific diseases like the “lousy disease” where your skin erupts to reveal thousands of writhing bugs, body snatchers, phobias, and stories of shock-therapy. I think that covers the horror aspect fairly well.

7. Would you tell us a story involving corpses? Those are always fun.

VV: With pleasure. How about the origins of the guillotine, so we’ll get corpses and execution.
Joseph-Ignace Guillotin is credited as having introduced a swift and painless device designed to execute people in a humane fashion. He tested this device on the necks of corpses in the BicĂȘtre Hospital in Paris and, by 1789, concluded that it was significantly more rapid and effective than the common axe. Although Guillotin, after whom the guillotine is named, is widely credited as having been the inventor of this device, it was, in fact, used in Italy, Germany, Scotland, and
France throughout the 16th century. He just perfected it.

8. Beyond Bizarre has a chapter called Tales from the Cryptids. What Crypto story could you share with us?

VV: My favorite is the story of Chessie, the American version of Scotland’s Loch Ness monster, Nessie. Chessie makes her home near Chesapeake Bay, near the nation’s capital. Reported sightings of Chessie describe her as 30 to 40 feet long and snakelike, with a football-shaped head. One Chessie sighting took place in the summer of 1984, when a fisherman idly observed some bluefin jumping clear of the water as he floated past Caddy Corner. All of a sudden, all bluefin activity stopped, and the ocean was eerily quiet for a moment as Chessie soundlessly glided past.

The term cryptozoology—the science of hidden animals— was invented in the 1950s by Bernard Heuvelmans. And right now I’m working on a book about mermaids. I guess they’d fall in that category. Kind of the most overlooked of the cryptids. A lot of people have accounts and sightings, but few come forward with the information. I find it fascination, especially stories of menacing mermaids. Not so pretty afterall…

9. Who are some famous personalities that you could share some strange facts about?

VV: Katharine Hepburn suffered from a phobia of dirty hair. When she was shooting films for Twentieth Century Fox, she would sniff the heads of the cast and crew to make sure their hair was squeaky clean. And Bela Lugosi, the actor who famously portrayed Dracula in the 1931 film, was buried wearing his Dracula cape. My favorite story is about Ulysses S. Grant and his wife’s prophetic leanings. She woke up on the morning of April 14, 1865, with the intense sense that she and her husband should get out of Washington, D.C., as soon as possible. They left that day, even though it meant standing up President Abraham Lincoln’s invitation to the theater. Remember what happened that evening? The bullet of John Wilkes Booth assassinated Lincoln. Papers discovered later revealed that Grant was also on the hit list. So this story not only encourages you to pay attention to that “gut-feeling” it also shows that you really should listen to your wife.

10. What are you up to in the future book wise or project wise and any links you would like to share? Also any last words as this interview closes in its final finale of gloom and glee? Thank you.

VV: Well I guess I already mentioned I have a book coming out in the summer of 2013 all about mermaids, called Among the Mermaids Facts, Myths, and Enchantments from the Sirens of the Sea. Following that I have a book called Banshees, Werewolves, Vampires, and Other Creatures of the Night. Both of these draw on and were inspired by my research for the Magical Creatures collection. Watch my blog, The Blog of the Bizarre, for upcoming dates, call for entries, and current giveaways for my books! You can also find me on Huffington Post, where I blog for their Weird News site, as well as on facebook and twitter.

Aye, we know there are many predators out there in the great, vast world. If we aren’t worried about the Zombie Apocalypse we are clutching our purses in fear of getting mugged. And thanks to medication, many of us who might stay up all night wrought with anxiety can get some sleep. I can tell you that what I’ve been reading, researching and writing about will not help ease any of your fears. In fact, it may well add to them. There are things lurking in the basement, outside the window, scratching at the door. There is no remedy, though there are some precautions you can take. Keep your silver bullets handy and your deadbolts locked. Consider yourself warned. And good luck.

http://varlaventura.wordpress.com/
http://www.huffingtonpost.com/varla-ventura/
https://www.facebook.com/varla.ventura
https://twitter.com/VarlaVentura

Jeffery Pritchett is the host of The Church Of Mabus Show bringing you high strange stories from professionals in the carousel of fields surrounding the paranormal.